Cappings
Pierce County Beekeeping Association
Monthly Newsletter
November 2024 - Volume 30 - Issue 11
President's Corner
Happy Thanksgiving
We have so much to be thankful for. I am grateful for family, friends and PCBA. I have met, gotten to know and become friends with so many great people. I am grateful that you trust me enough to continue on another year as your president. It is truly an honor. As we move into the holidays and then winter, the PCBA Board and I will continue to serve and make this Association one you can be proud to be a member of. I hope to see you at our Holiday Desert Reception and White Elephant Party in December!
The Bee Attitude
by Breanna Opdahl
Bees are amazing insects, and as I’m sure you are aware our world would not exist without them. Not only are they beneficial to our physical health but our mental health as well.
​
I have noticed in my personal life the calming effects the bees have on me when I go out to visit them. I get lost in the soothing buzz of the busy bees going about their day avoiding our pet chickens and ducks with whom they share their outside dwelling and not
particularly noticing that I am there.
I have autism and ADHD so the world can be too noisy and chaotic for me. I find solace and comfort in the familiarity of my bees. I know I’m not the only one...
​
At the Monachyle Mhor Hotel in Crieff, Perthshire Scotland, people pay to sleep on beds made of beehive boxes (with the bees still in them). The buzzing soothes away the guests' worries and helps them to sleep. (Sign me up!)
​
I read "Song of Increase: Listening to the Wisdom of the Honeybees for Kinder Beekeeping and a Better World” by Jacqueline Freeman (a local beekeeper). In her book, she talks about the joys of setting up a folding chair next to her hives and spending time with her bees.
There have been many studies over the years studying the positive mental health effects of keeping bees and the biggest find is mindfulness and a sense of wellbeing.
​
With that I encourage you this next spring and summer to take a folding chair and cold drink out to your beehives and feel the buzz!
We have a new fundraising program!!!
You will now be able to buy PCBA Merch. For us "Oldies", that's Merchandise!
Follow the link to the online store.
https://stores.thetsmshop.com/pcbeekeepers
Choose your color and size.
Choose large or small logo.
Youth sizes available.
Become a Member of PCBA!
It has been an amazing year and we have so much more to come! Over the year we have gathered over 800 members of our Facebook Group and over 650 Newsletter Subscribers! We are elated and honored to have had such a successful reach. Now, please be reminded that we are a Non-Profit 501c3. Membership makes a massive impact to our ability to continue full steam ahead and offer classes and programs that you all value, in fact it's the only way... We are asking all of you that are participating on our social platforms and subscribing to please sign up for membership in 2024 and help us continue to grow our resources and programs.
*** When we changed website hosts last year, everyone who became a member was considered a "New" member as far as the computer was concerned. The New Member choice does not automatically renew every year. We have just learned that anyone who signed up last year will need to join again on your expiration date.
IT DOES NOT AUTOMATICALLY RENEW YOUR MEMBERSHIP.
Many people have expired memberships. If you got an email that told you to renew and then on the website it said that you had already purchased the membership and then wouldn't let you renew, that was a computer glitch that is now fixed.
Please check your records to find the date you joined or renewed last year and rejoin if your membership is expired by date. The automatic renewal is working for some.
If you are unsure of your status you can email president@pcbeekeepers.org
Thank you
​
Become a Member
2024 EVENTS & PROJECTS
Members, we need you! Pierce County Beekeepers Association couldn’t happen without you, our volunteers! Please sign up to help with the upcoming events. It is a great time to get to know other members and educate the community about the bees and what our organization is all about. Some of these events are fundraisers where we will be selling honey.
From brand new beekeeper to experienced beekeeper, you have a place at our table! You pick your comfort level, from selling the honey/ raffle tickets to just talking about bees. Come and join the fun!!
​
Important dates in 2024
HERE IS A LINK TO OUR 2024 CALENDAR OF EVENTS
Holiday Party on December 2nd - Allmendinger Center
Hive Host & Beekeeper List
We have many hosts, but we need more BEEKEEPERS! We have been building a list of those who have properties in which they are aiming to host hives on, as well as beekeepers who would like to service hives on host properties. With Spring coming, it is time to sign up! To join this list and be matched with a potential host or beekeeper, please sign up here: https://www.pcbeekeepers.org/hive-host-and-beekeeper-list
Monthly Meeting Information
Monday, December 2nd
Holiday Party, Dessert Reception and White Elephant Exchange
Bring a dessert to share. Bring a White Elephant Gift if you want to Participate in the White Elephant exchange. It's really a lot of fun.
Gift limit $20
​
Here is a definition of a "White Elephant" gift but feel free to bring a gift of your choosing.​
A white elephant gift exchange, Yankee swap or Dirty Santa is a party game where amusing and impractical gifts are exchanged during festivities. The goal of a white elephant gift exchange is to entertain party-goers rather than to give or acquire a genuinely valuable or highly sought item
Party starts at 6pm​​​
D.F. Allmendinger Center
2606 W Pioneer Ave, Puyallup, WA 98371
Apiary Day & Workshop Information
Apiary Days are weather dependent will begin in May and run through October
Upcoming Apiary Days
​​
Apiary Days are done for the season! - Club Apiary
​
BRING YOUR BEE SUIT!!
Please keep an eye on our Facebook Group to keep up with any updates on what is planned for the next upcoming, including estimated times and lesson plan.
Contact Katie Marler education@pcbeekeepers.org with any questions.
Beekeeping Class Information
Classes are available to PCBA Members only - Become a Member
Sign up for Classes on our Website
WSU Puyallup Research & Extension Center
D.F. Allmendinger Center
2606 W Pioneer Ave, Puyallup, WA 98371
Classes are January - November
Please keep an eye on our Facebook Group & your email to keep up with any updates on what is planned for the next upcoming, including estimated times and lesson plan.
Contact Katie Marler education@pcbeekeepers.org with any questions.
​How Cold is Too Cold for OAV?
Article and Photos by Frank Mortimer, Cornell University Master Beekeeper
Featured by Kathleen Clerc
Since more and more beekeepers are using oxalic acid to treat for mites, it’s important for PCBA members to understand the research behind the treatments so as to use it safely and effectively. I researched scientific, peer-reviewed journal articles to find out more about oxalic acid treatments for honey bees. This article is a synthesis by Frank Mortimer of Cornell University and does not contain any opinions.
As any good beekeeper knows, Varroa destructor is the number one threat to Apis Mellifera and is responsible for more deaths of honey bee colonies than any other contributing factor. According to Cornell University, since Varroa mites first entered the United States in 1987, they have become even more deadly to our colonies because the bees no longer can handle mite loads as high as they once could. Varroa is a carrier of multiple bee-killing viruses so it now takes fewer mites to devastate honey bee colonies, which is why monitoring mite levels and developing a yearly treatment calendar is essential to keeping honey bees alive.
Oxalic acid (OA) as a treatment for Varroa is still relatively new in the United States, with the EPA having approved it in March of 2015. As more beekeepers start using OA, more questions arise regarding how to use it effectively as a mite treatment. Since OA is best used when a colony is broodless, one of the most frequently asked questions is in regard to outside temperature. When is it too cold to treat? At what temperatures is OA still effective? Because oxalic acid has been used to combat Varroa mites in Europe for decades, the author reviewed scientific studies and found that a lot of research has been done in European countries where OA has been used for many years. Some of that research specifically mentions temperature in regard to treatments. All the information that I’ve included comes from reviewed journal articles, meaning that the scientific community has deemed that the science behind these studies is accurate and valid.
In the first study, Rademacher and Harz (1) provide data supporting that OA can be sublimated (vaporized) when outside temperatures are greater than 2° Celsius (35° Fahrenheit). The article also states that the dribble method of delivering OA requires an outside temperature that is greater than 3° C (37.4° F). Their research is a reminder that people in other countries think about temperature differently than we in WA might. What’s cold in Sweden is certainly different than what’s cold in Egypt, yet Apis m. is native to both regions and can therefore tolerate both versions of what is considered cold. While it might be hard to imagine dribbling any liquid onto bees when the outside temperature is only 37.4° F, it’s important not to anthropomorphize the honey bees, remembering instead that they are insects and temperature affects them differently than it does humans.
In the second study conducted by Rosenkranz, Aumeier, & Ziegelmann (2), data concluded that OA applied by trickling, spraying, fumigating, or as pure crystals (e.g. vaporized with heat) has an efficacy greater than 90% when colonies are broodless, and less than 60% when there is brood present. More importantly, it answers our question by stating that “efficacy is independent from temperature.” In other words, temperature has no impact on how effective OA is at killing mites. It works no matter what the outside temperature is. The third study by Charriére & Imdorf (3) simply recommends that beekeepers “carry out treatment at an outdoor temperature of above 0°C (32° Fahrenheit).”
The last study by Radetzki & Bärmann (4) appeared on the Swedish beekeeping site, “Alltom Biodling.” What I found especially interesting about this study is that it shows the impact that the outside temperature has on the OA treatment’s effectiveness. Most importantly, the effectiveness didn’t drop off until they treated at -2°C to 0°C (28.4°F to 32°F). Since most people reading this article are not fluent in Swedish, below is a table from the study where the author added the English words for clarity.
​
​Based on a review of the scientific literature, treating with OA in any temperature above freezing — 0° Celsius, 32° Fahrenheit — will be an effective Varroa treatment if beekeepers use sublimation (vaporization). The dribble method is also effective but only at a slightly higher temperature of 37.4°. The research also supports that OA is most effective when a hive is broodless, which coincides with temperatures in NJ generally dipping down into the low thirties. Therefore, to ensure its maximum effectiveness, beekeepers should schedule oxalic acid treatments during the winter months when brood levels are at their lowest point, knowing that they need not be as concerned about the outside temperatures as much as with keeping their bees healthy via low mite counts.
​
by Charlotte Anderson
As the honey harvesting season draws to a close, beekeepers face the issue of how to store honey supers over winter. Drawn comb, spare boxes and other pieces associated with honey production need a place to stay when not on the hive. These are valuable pieces of beekeeping equipment. Taking good care of them will help the colonies get off to a better start next Spring.
​
A successful beekeeper learns how to manage their beehives-eventually. But, he/she must also manage the beekeeping equipment and supplies needed throughout the year. For each colony you will need several super boxes for honey. Not every box will be in use throughout the year.
​
In most regions, bees only make honey during the warm months. This is the time when the boxes called “honey supers” will be on the hive to collect honey for the beekeeper.
​
We are not talking about boxes that are left on the hive year round for the bees to use. This is one of those situations where “beekeeping terminology” can get you in trouble. Not everyone of us use the same words for the same thing!
After harvesting your honey, those “honey super boxes” are no longer needed on the hive because the production season is over.
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
Now, the beekeeper is faced with needing a safe place to store honey supers with drawn combover the cold months of the year. Finding a way to store other pieces of beekeeping equipment over winter or when no in use is easier than those containing comb.
​​
When to Remove Honey Supers for Winter
Knowing when to remove honey supers for Winter can be a bit tricky. No exact calendar date can be given – it depends greatly on your location. Some regions experience cold temps much sooner than others. And, in addition to cold weather, it also depends on your local nectar sources.
​
In upstate South Carolina, I know that my bees will not make any excess honey for me after the Sourwood Bloom in June-July. There is no need to put honey supers back on the hive after that time.
However, if you live in a region with a long, mild Fall and plenty of nectar rich Fall bee flowers – your boxes can stay on longer. Before true cold weather arrives, get extra boxes and queen excluders off the hive. Complete any needed varroa mite treatments and get those hives ready for the cold months ahead.
​
Frames With Honeycomb at Risk
The most difficult task facing a beekeeper is storing empty wax frames. This refers to any frames with wax comb but no honey – after the honey extraction process. These frames are called “drawn comb” and are very valuable. A colony must invest a lot of time and bee energy into building wax comb.
​
Because empty frames of honeycomb can be reused next season, finding a proper storage place for your wax comb is a priority. However, you cannot store honey supers with drawn comb just anywhere. Many beekeepers are dismayed each Spring to find their beautiful frames of wax comb destroyed.
​
Wax Moth Infestations
It is usually the pesky wax moth larvae that are responsible for the damage. They consume the wax and leave behind a mess. Even the beekeeper using plastic foundation should practice care with comb storage. Pests are not able to completely destroy plastic. But, they can still make a mess of it and leave the bees with a lot of extra work to do.
​
But I didn’t see any moth eggs !! No, normally you won’t but that doesn’t mean they were not there. Any frames of comb that have been removed from the hive (not protected by bees)- may have wax moth eggs.
​
Once in a dark warm place, these eggs hatch into moth larvae. Moth larva hatch and tunnel through the comb in search of pollen, bee bread and bee pupal cocoons. Leaving behind a mess of webbing and feces, the beekeeper must spend time and money installing new beeswax foundation. And besides is it a nasty mess to clean up!
The warmer your climate, the more issues you are likely to face with these honey bee pests. But even areas with cold months when temperatures are low are not completely safe from moth damage.​ Comb that has only held honey (not been used for brood rearing) is not as desirable to the moth. However, even honey frames will have some pollen from time to time so it is best to provide protection. You may also find earwigs (a lesser pest) setting up house keeping in your drawn comb. They are a pest but for the most part only a minor problem for bees. They do no real damage to your comb.
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
Protecting Stored Honey Supers
There are several strategies used by beekeeper to protect drawn comb frames in supers.
-
freeze prior to storage (or keep frozen)
-
outside storage in light airy location
-
chemical protection
​
Freezing Frames for Storage
Once the honey supers are removed from the hive, the bees are not around to police the comb and remove moth eggs or larva. That job falls to you – the beekeeper. You cannot rely on “seeing” moth eggs. It is best to assume there are some in there and take action.
​
If you are storing honey supers of a small number, the freezer method can work well. Freeze your frames of comb for 2 or 3 days to kill any wax moth eggs. (Tip: freezing honey is a great way to store it in the comb for the bees or you next year.)
​
Remove the frames of comb from the freezer (let thaw & dry in a secure place (where moths can’t get) and then seal in plastic bags or bins. Prevent re-infestation by securing the bags tightly. Otherwise, you may be in for a big, nasty surprise when you open that bag in several months.
​
Admittedly, this method takes some time and space. Because beeswax is fragile, it is easiest to store honey frames in the wooden super to avoid breaking comb. So you will probably be storing the whole box – gotta think about the space needed. Freezing also works as a good storage method for raw honeycomb intended for human consumption. Just be sure to wrap it up tight first.
​
Open Shed with Light and Air
Another option for those without freezer space for all those supers and frames. Storing your beekeeping supers in an open shed. Wax Moths do not like light. They desire the dark inside of a bee hive (or a garbage bag – or tightly stacked supers..) Beekeepers use this moth behavior to our advantage by storing bee boxes in a special stack method. If you have the space, it can work for you too.
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
Stacking honey supers (with comb inside) in a criss-cross fashion inside an open air shed is a favorite method. More light and air will circulate through the boxes – deterring moth activity. That does not mean you will have zero damage but it does help.
A roof over the top protects the stored honey supers from rain. Adding wire sides lets light inside and prevents raccoons from eating your comb! (Trust me – I know.) Cold weather is good for super storage. Once the temps turn cold – wax moth damage is not a threat.
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​​
Using BT for Moth Control
The form of BT known as bacillus thuringiensis is used by some beekeepers to protect comb frames.​ In previous years, it was sold under the product label Certan and is back on the market as B402 Certan. It is labeled for use in bees and helps control wax moths in stored comb.
It is mixed with water and sprayed on new foundation or honeycomb. This would be done before placing boxes on the hive or after removing them. BT kills wax moth larvae.
​
Certan has been brought back to the US and is available in some bee supplies. Xentari (the same form of BT) is also sold in the US but availability is limited and it may not be labeled for use around bees.
​​
Protecting Supers with Paradicholorbenzene
PDB (Para Dicholorobenzene) is a chemical compound in a crystal form labeled for bees and approved by the FDA. The pack of crystals is placed near stored honey supers to control wax moths. This chemical is also a known carcinogen and has a very pungent odor. I have never used it.
​
Do not use regular moth balls – the chemical is often not the same and can dangerous to you and the hive.
How to Protect Stored Honeycomb from Mice
In some regions of the country, mice can be a major pest during the cold months. They even sneak into live hives while the bees are clustered in the top keeping warm. Consider placing a mouse guard over the entrance to your hive if you live in a region where they are prevalent. This is a larger issues in areas with long cold Winters. Don’t delay, have your mouse guards on before cold arrives. Or, your mice tenants may already be in there!
​​
Even in mild regions, stored honey supers can attract mice. A lot of comb is destroyed as a result of the chewing and body wastes. Both wax and frames may be ruined. Traps can be utilized if needed to large populations of mice. When stacking supers, using a queen excluder on the bottom and top of the stack can help too!
​
Can You Leave a Honey Super on Over Winter?
Yes, you can leave a honey super or several on the hive. In fact, most beekeepers do have a super or two designated for use by the bees. The size of the box (boxes) designated as the “food super” for the bees varies from one beekeeper to another and from one region to another.
​
Preparing beehives for the cold months or winterizing hives involves several checks – including evaluation of their food reserves. Honey bees survive the cold by consuming stored honey.
In any region with cold weather, the amount of honey stored in just a single brood box (usually one deep) would not be enough. In some areas of the country – two deeps boxes are used for Winter.
​
In addition to having healthy colonies, overwintering bees involves learning how many boxes of food to leave on the hives. Consult with local experienced beekeepers or beekeeping associations about how much honey your colonies need. While an average of 60# or stored honey is often used as a measurement – each location is different. Local groups can help you ensure that your bees have enough honey to avoid starvation.
​
Bees Can Have Too Much Space to Guard
However, leaving too much space on the hive has risks as well. During late Fall and early Spring, when colony populations are low – the bees may not be able to protect all that comb.​ Therefore, it is best to remove any boxes beyond what the bees need for Winter survival. This should leave the colony with ample space but not too much territory to defend.
​
When cold temperatures arrives, the bees will cluster in the brood chamber of the hive. Even strong colonies will not need as much space to spread out.
​
FAQs
How should you store bee combs?
The safest ways to protect valuable empty honeycomb is to freeze it, then store in an air-tight container, or store frames of comb exposed to light and air or use a chemical treatment to deter wax moths.
​
Can you store honeycomb frames in a freezer that doesn’t work?
Yes, the seals of the unit will keep out all insects but you need to freeze or treat the comb first to kill or remove any eggs.
​
Can you freeze plastic bee frames with comb?
Yes. While wax moths do not destroy plastic foundation to the extent of wax – they will ruin the honeycomb cells. Freeze them before storage in an air-tight container.
​​
Final Thoughts
Finding a safe place to keep unused equipment or frames with only foundation is not too hard. However, anything involving comb requires a bit more thought. This is a great time to inspect frames and comb, replace any dark black honeycomb and you will have healthier bees.
​
Protect your investment in effort and money, develop a plan, learn how to store all beekeeping supplies until needed again next year. But, storing valuable honey supers with drawn comb should be a top priority.
​
​
I don't know about you but a lot of my colonies just didn't make a lot of honey this year. Then a visitor that came to the booth at the fair showed me this Penn State study. I found it interesting and something to ponder.
​
Why are bees making less honey? Study reveals clues in five decades of data.
Click on the button to go to the study
Beekeeping Articles & Topics of Interest
Beekeeping, for Veterans - https://wafarmvetco.org/healing-through-hives
Northwest bees flying during mild winter weather are less likely to survive till spring, WSU researchers find -https://www.opb.org/article/2024/06/02/northwest-bees-mild-winter-survival/?outputType=amp​​
​​
WSU Bees + Pollinator Program - https://bees.wsu.edu/september-2024/
Resource List for Diagnostic Testing of Honey Bees 2024
(information provided by, Bri Price, WSU Honey Bee Program Extension Coordinator)
If you want an answer on the cause of the death of your bees, the following is a list of organizations in the United States that may be able to assist you. For a compete list of diagnostic labs and what they will test go to this website: https://apiaryinspectors.org/page-18060.
If you believe the apiary was damaged through the use of pesticides and if you have registered your hive(s) with the State Department of Agriculture, you can also contact Katie Buckley (Pollinator Health Coordinator) with the WA Dept of Agriculture, and report the situation as a potential bee kill: kbuckley@agr.wa.gov. They usually only formally investigate if it is a large number of hives that were killed. WSU Bee Program used to have a diagnostic lab but does not currently have one. For now, they recommend that people send their bees to the Beltsville Bee Lab; it’s a free source in Maryland. This facility tests for bacterial, fungal and microsporidian diseases, two species of parasitic mites, and other honey bee pests. They also test for American Foul brood when requested. But this lab does not test for viruses or pesticides.
The following all charge for their testing services:
VIRUS TESTING (not pesticides)
• North Carolina State (https://www.ncsuapiculture.net/queen-and-disease-clinic) o Fees range from $24-320
• National Agricultural Genotyping Center (https://www.genotypingcenter.com/honey-bee-pathogen-panel/) o Fees range from $60-300
PESTICIDE TESTING (not viruses)
• Cornell Chemical Ecology Core Facility (https://blogs.cornell.edu/ccecf/the-facility/) o $90
• USDA-AMS National Science Laboratory (https://www.ams.usda.gov/services/lab-testing/nsl) o $450
• Synergistic Pesticide Laboratory (https://synpestlab.com/services/) o This is a lab that WSU’s bee program has used, direct contact: Camille Holladay cholladay@synpestlab.com o Fees range from $160-365​
​
​
Ask a Washington Beekeeper - WASBA
WASBA’s ongoing project “Ask a Washington Beekeeper” has two episodes in the books. The first, in October, featured Jeff Ott and Bri Price, whose presentation about preparing for winter reached about two dozen interested beekeepers via both Facebook Live and Zoom. WASBA board member Dawn Beck graciously shared her presentation about the honeybees’ fat bodies and how these relate to honeybee health. In both cases, the presenters fielded questions from the audience with questions ranging from combining hives to winter survival rates. “Ask a Washington Beekeeper” is a collaboration between WASBA and GRuB and is designed to reach beekeepers who may be in outlying areas without access to a mentor or a beekeeping club. Our goal is to provide information, education and mentoring to as many people as possible, including veterans who are interested in beekeeping. An educated beekeeper is a better beekeeper and is better for the beekeeping community.
After a break for the holiday, “Ask a Washington Beekeeper” will resume on January 18th with WASBA president Alan Woods sharing his knowledge about integrated pest management. Future programs include information about packaged bees vs. nucs, a panel discussion, and information about the nectar flow. Programs are each month on the third Thursday starting at 6:30pm. Check it out and tell your friends – here’s the link: https://www.facebook.com/AskAWABeekeeper. We’ll see you there!
​